Improving Freeway Crash Prediction Models Using Disaggregate Flow State Information PDF Download
Are you looking for read ebook online? Search for your book and save it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. Download Improving Freeway Crash Prediction Models Using Disaggregate Flow State Information PDF full book. Access full book title Improving Freeway Crash Prediction Models Using Disaggregate Flow State Information by Nancy Dutta. Download full books in PDF and EPUB format.
Author: Nancy Dutta Publisher: ISBN: Category : Traffic accidents Languages : en Pages : 58
Book Description
Crash analysis methods typically use annual average daily traffic as an exposure measure, which can be too aggregate to capture the safety effects of variations in traffic flow and operations that occur throughout the day. Flow characteristics such as variation in speed and level of congestion play a significant role in crash occurrence and are not currently accounted for in the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials’ Highway Safety Manual. This study developed a methodology for creating crash prediction models using traffic, geometric, and control information that is provided at sub-daily aggregation intervals. Data from 110 rural four-lane segments and 80 urban six-lane segments were used. The volume data used in this study came from detectors that collect data ranging from continuous counts throughout the year to counts from only a couple of weeks every other year (short counts). Speed data were collected from both point sensors and probe data provided by INRIX. The results showed that models that used data aggregated to an average hourly level reflected the variation in volume and speed throughout the day without compromising model quality. Crash predictions for urban segments underwent a 20% improvement in mean absolute deviation for total crashes and a 9% improvement for injury crashes when models using average hourly volume, geometry, and flow variables were compared to the model based on annual average daily traffic. Corresponding improvements over annual average daily traffic models for rural segments were 11% and 9%. Average hourly speed, standard deviation of hourly speed, and differences between speed limit and average speed had statistically significant relationships with crash frequency. For all models, prediction accuracy was improved across all validation measures of effectiveness when the speed components were added. The positive effect of flow variables was true irrespective of the speed data source. Further investigation revealed that the improvement achieved in model prediction by using a more inclusive and bigger dataset was larger than the effect of accounting for spatial/temporal data correlation. For rural hourly models, mean absolute deviation improved by 52% when short counts were added in comparison to the continuous count station only models. The respective value for urban segments was 58%. This means that using short count stations as a data source does not diminish the quality of the developed models. Thus, a combination of different volume data sources with good quality speed data can lessen the dependency on volume data quality without compromising performance. Although accounting for spatial and temporal correlation improved model performance, it provided smaller benefits than inclusion of the short count data in the models. This study showed that it is possible to develop a broadly transferable crash prediction methodology using hourly level volume and flow data that are currently widely available to transportation agencies. These models have a broad spectrum of potential applications that involve assessing safety effects of events and countermeasures that create recurring and non-recurring short-term fluctuations in traffic characteristics.
Author: Nancy Dutta Publisher: ISBN: Category : Traffic accidents Languages : en Pages : 58
Book Description
Crash analysis methods typically use annual average daily traffic as an exposure measure, which can be too aggregate to capture the safety effects of variations in traffic flow and operations that occur throughout the day. Flow characteristics such as variation in speed and level of congestion play a significant role in crash occurrence and are not currently accounted for in the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials’ Highway Safety Manual. This study developed a methodology for creating crash prediction models using traffic, geometric, and control information that is provided at sub-daily aggregation intervals. Data from 110 rural four-lane segments and 80 urban six-lane segments were used. The volume data used in this study came from detectors that collect data ranging from continuous counts throughout the year to counts from only a couple of weeks every other year (short counts). Speed data were collected from both point sensors and probe data provided by INRIX. The results showed that models that used data aggregated to an average hourly level reflected the variation in volume and speed throughout the day without compromising model quality. Crash predictions for urban segments underwent a 20% improvement in mean absolute deviation for total crashes and a 9% improvement for injury crashes when models using average hourly volume, geometry, and flow variables were compared to the model based on annual average daily traffic. Corresponding improvements over annual average daily traffic models for rural segments were 11% and 9%. Average hourly speed, standard deviation of hourly speed, and differences between speed limit and average speed had statistically significant relationships with crash frequency. For all models, prediction accuracy was improved across all validation measures of effectiveness when the speed components were added. The positive effect of flow variables was true irrespective of the speed data source. Further investigation revealed that the improvement achieved in model prediction by using a more inclusive and bigger dataset was larger than the effect of accounting for spatial/temporal data correlation. For rural hourly models, mean absolute deviation improved by 52% when short counts were added in comparison to the continuous count station only models. The respective value for urban segments was 58%. This means that using short count stations as a data source does not diminish the quality of the developed models. Thus, a combination of different volume data sources with good quality speed data can lessen the dependency on volume data quality without compromising performance. Although accounting for spatial and temporal correlation improved model performance, it provided smaller benefits than inclusion of the short count data in the models. This study showed that it is possible to develop a broadly transferable crash prediction methodology using hourly level volume and flow data that are currently widely available to transportation agencies. These models have a broad spectrum of potential applications that involve assessing safety effects of events and countermeasures that create recurring and non-recurring short-term fluctuations in traffic characteristics.
Author: Mirza Ahammad Sharif Publisher: ISBN: Category : Languages : en Pages :
Book Description
Motor vehicle crashes in the United States continue to be a serious safety concern for state highway agencies, with over 30,000 fatal crashes reported each year. The World Health Organization (WHO) reported in 2016 that vehicle crashes were the eighth leading cause of death globally. Crashes on roadways are rare and random events that occur due to the result of the complex relationship between the driver, vehicle, weather, and roadway. A significant breadth of research has been conducted to predict and understand why crashes occur through spatial and temporal analyses, understanding information about the driver and roadway, and identification of hazardous locations through geographic information system (GIS) applications. Also, previous research studies have investigated the effectiveness of safety devices designed to reduce the number and severity of crashes. Today, data-driven traffic safety studies are becoming an essential aspect of the planning, design, construction, and maintenance of the roadway network. This can only be done with the assistance of state highway agencies collecting and synthesizing historical crash data, roadway geometry data, and environmental data being collected every day at a resolution that will help researchers develop powerful crash prediction tools. The objective of this research study was to predict vehicle crashes in real-time. This exploratory analysis compared three well-known machine learning methods, including logistic regression, random forest, support vector machine. Additionally, another methodology was developed using variables selected from random forest models that were inserted into the support vector machine model. The study review of the literature noted that this study's selected methods were found to be more effective in terms of prediction power. A total of 475 crashes were identified from the selected urban highway network in Kansas City, Kansas. For each of the 475 identified crashes, six no-crash events were collected at the same location. This was necessary so that the predictive models could distinguish a crash-prone traffic operational condition from regular traffic flow conditions. Multiple data sources were fused to create a database including traffic operational data from the KC Scout traffic management center, crash and roadway geometry data from the Kanas Department of Transportation; and weather data from NOAA. Data were downloaded from five separate roadway radar sensors close to the crash location. This enable understanding of the traffic flow along the roadway segment (upstream and downstream) during the crash. Additionally, operational data from each radar sensor were collected in five minutes intervals up to 30 minutes prior to a crash occurring. Although six no-crash events were collected for each crash observation, the ratio of crash and no-crash were then reduced to 1:4 (four non-crash events), and 1:2 (two non-crash events) to investigate possible effects of class imbalance on crash prediction. Also, 60%, 70%, and 80% of the data were selected in training to develop each model. The remaining data were then used for model validation. The data used in training ratios were varied to identify possible effects of training data as it relates to prediction power. Additionally, a second database was developed in which variables were log-transformed to reduce possible skewness in the distribution. Model results showed that the size of the dataset increased the overall accuracy of crash prediction. The dataset with a higher observation count could classify more data accurately. The highest accuracies in all three models were observed using the dataset of a 1:6 ratio (one crash event for six no-crash events). The datasets with1:2 ratio predicted 13% to 18% lower than the 1:6 ratio dataset. However, the sensitivity (true positive prediction) was observed highest for the dataset of a 1:2 ratio. It was found that reducing the response class imbalance; the sensitivity could be increased with the disadvantage of a reduction in overall prediction accuracy. The effects of the split ratio were not significantly different in overall accuracy. However, the sensitivity was found to increase with an increase in training data. The logistic regression model found an average of 30.79% (with a standard deviation of 5.02) accurately. The random forest models predicted an average of 13.36% (with a standard deviation of 9.50) accurately. The support vector machine models predicted an average of 29.35% (with a standard deviation of 7.34) accurately. The hybrid approach of random forest and support vector machine models predicted an average of 29.86% (with a standard deviation of 7.33) accurately. The significant variables found from this study included the variation in speed between the posted speed limit and average roadway traffic speed around the crash location. The variations in speed and vehicle per hour between upstream and downstream traffic of a crash location in the previous five minutes before a crash occurred were found to be significant as well. This study provided an important step in real-time crash prediction and complemented many previous research studies found in the literature review. Although the models investigate were somewhat inconclusive, this study provided an investigation of data, variables, and combinations of variables that have not been investigated previously. Real-time crash prediction is expected to assist with the on-going development of connected and autonomous vehicles as the fleet mix begins to change, and new variables can be collected, and data resolution becomes greater. Real-time crash prediction models will also continue to advance highway safety as metropolitan areas continue to grow, and congestion continues to increase.
Author: Publisher: ISBN: Category : Roads Languages : en Pages : 138
Book Description
The release of the Highway Safety Manual (HSM) by the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) in 2010 was a landmark event in the practice of road safety analysis. Before it, the United States had no central repository for information about quantitative road safety analysis methodology. The TRB National Cooperative Highway Research Program's NCHRP Web-Only Document 295: Improved Prediction Models for Crash Types and Crash Severities describes efforts to develop improved crash prediction methods for crash type and severity for the three facility types covered in the HSM—specifically, two‐lane rural highways, multilane rural highways, and urban/suburban arterials. Supplemental materials to the Web-Only Document include Appendices A, B, and C (Average Condition Models, Crash Severities – Ordered Probit Fractional Split Modeling Approach, and Draft Content for Highway Safety Manual, 2nd Edition).
Author: Gaurav Satish Mehta Publisher: ISBN: Category : Electronic dissertations Languages : en Pages : 158
Book Description
Providing safe travel from one point to another is the main objective of any public transportation agency. The recent publication of the Highway Safety Manual (HSM) has resulted in an increasing emphasis on the safety performance of specific roadway facilities. The HSM provides tools such as crash prediction models that can be used to make informed decisions. The manual is a good starting point for transportation agencies interested in improving roadway safety in their states. However, the models published in the manual need calibration to account for the local driver behavior and jurisdictional changes. The method provided in the HSM for calibrating crash prediction models is not scientific and has been proved inefficient by several studies. To overcome this limitation this study proposes two alternatives. Firstly, a new method is proposed for calibrating the crash prediction models using negative binomial regression. Secondly, this study investigates new forms of state-specific Safety Performance Function SPFs using negative binomial techniques. The HSM's 1st edition provides a multiplier applied to the univariate crash prediction models to estimate the expected number of crashes for different crash severities. It does not consider the distinct effect unobserved heterogeneity might have on crash severities. To address this limitation, this study developed a multivariate extension of the Conway Maxwell Poisson distribution for predicting crashes. This study gives the statistical properties and the parameter estimation algorithm for the distribution. The last part of this dissertation extends the use of Highway Safety Manual by developing a multivariate crash prediction model for the bridge section of the roads. The study then compares the performance of the newly proposed multivariate Conway Maxwell Poisson (MVCMP) model with the multivariate Poisson Lognormal, univariate Conway Maxwell Poisson (UCMP) and univariate Poisson Lognormal model for different crash severities. This example will help transportation researchers in applying the model correctly.
Author: Abdulla Ali Publisher: ISBN: Category : Traffic accident investigation Languages : en Pages : 306
Book Description
Vehicle crashes on roadways are one of the most challenging problems affecting many parts of the world. Michigan, having freeways that progressively get busier each year, has also seen an increase in vehicle crashes. These crashes are due to several factors including human errors, roadway deficiencies, environmental factors, vehicle factors, etc. A study conducted by Michigan Traffic Crash Facts (MTCF) estimates a crash will happen every 44 minutes and a person will die every six hours on Michigan roadways. The success of traffic safety and highway improvement programs depends on the analysis of accurate and reliable vehicle crash data. This study intended to find the effect of the speed limit and road and weather conditions on the frequency of crashes in the investigated black spots and the effect of using the driving simulator to establish crash modification factor on decreasing the number of crashes. This study discusses the traffic information on 18 freeways in the State of Michigan in the years 2010-2014. High crash rate locations (black spots) and safety deficient areas on the highways were identified by using Geographic Information System (GIS) software. Two statistical black spot identification techniques, Kernel Density Estimation (KDE) and Point Density Estimation (PDE), were used. By comparing the two methods, our research found that KDE is more capable of pinpointing black spots than the PDE method. The KDE study revealed a black spot on a section of I-69 in Flint, Michigan. From this data, ten different driving simulator scenarios were developed with the same roadway track. To better understand driver behavior and responses, different road and weather conditions were incorporated. By using an Internet Scene Assembler (ISA) and SimCreator, making various changes to the driving tests were simplified. Using a multi-user driver simulator environment, different contributing factors for crashes were created and countermeasures were tested. One hundred subjects (81 males and 19 females) were recruited from the Lawrence Technological University (LTU) community to participate in this driver simulator study. Resulting data were analyzed. From this analysis, a predictive model that focused on driving behavior was developed and based on easily interpretable variables. The categories of the independent variable (speed limit, speeding, brake respond) were considered nominal. To determine the possible factors contributing to a crash type, the multinomial logistic regression model (MNL) was fitted to the set of available independent variables. After developing the MNL model fitted with data explanatory variables, certain crash types were observed as being statistically significant. Speeding and speed limit during certain inclement road/weather conditions had the greatest effect on crashes. The subjectivity of the driver’s perception of the safety and effectiveness of countermeasures were considered using fuzzy mathematics. The driver data were used as input into a fuzzy model using the fuzzy rule base. A safety level was compared to speed limits to determine if the proposed speed limit contributed to a risky or safe situation. The fuzzy model showed that in snowy and icy weather conditions the speed limit has to be reduced from 70 mph by 10-20 mph. In this study, the Crash Modification Factors (CMF) for selected countermeasures were estimated using the driver simulator scenarios. The expected CMF gives the notion of whether a treatment or a change in the speed limit in certain weather conditions will lead to change in the number of crashes and consequently a change in the safety level. The results concluded that most frequent crashes occur during snowy and icy weather conditions and by changing the speed limit during these weather conditions, the number of road crashes can be reduced. These crash reductions can be shown as CMFs. The method of developing CMFs used in this study is considered a new dimension that will increase road safety and reduce the rate of road traffic crashes. Keywords: Kernel Density Estimation (KDE) and Point Density Estimation (PDE), logistic regression model, fuzzy mathematics, Crash Modification Factors (CMF).
Author: Srutha Vavilikolanu Publisher: ISBN: Category : Bayesian statistical decision theory Languages : en Pages : 122
Book Description
"According to Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), truck involvement in fatal crashes is more on rural areas than on urban areas. The Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS) encyclopedia also indicates that truck involvement in fatal crashes are approximately 12% of the total fatal crashes in the nation and 14 % in The State of Ohio. One area for potential concern is the role of vertical curves on truck crashes. In the design of vertical curves stopping distance, grade and length of the curve are important factors taken into consideration. Vehicle operations on vertical curves are influenced by the grade of the curve, stopping sight distance and vehicle speed. These factors may create operational issues for vehicles traveling on vertical curves and in turn increase the likelihood for crashes. Truck specific studies in the past have focused on geometric roadway factors associated with crashes on vertical curves. Most of the research studies are focused on crest curve truck crashes, and little research has been done on crashes on vertical sag curves. The main research goal of the study is to develop prediction models to evaluate the impact of geometry, traffic volumes and speed on truck-related crashes on two-lane rural vertical curves. The accomplishment of the research goal is achieved by setting five objectives. The first objective is to develop three crash prediction models using negative binomial regression model. These models are 1. Full model - for all vertical curves 2. Reduced model I - for crest curves only and 3. Reduced model II - for sag curves only. The dataset includes 1,935 vertical curve segments with 205 truck crashes from 2002-2006. In second and third objective, Full Bayes approach is used to enhance the results obtained in the Reduced Models I and II. These results are then compared to the initial models. The fourth objective is evaluating the vertical curve variables which are statistically significant with truck-related crashes. These results show that higher grade change for the length of the vertical curve, total width in the range of 24 to 26ft, more number of passenger cars and trucks, increases the truck-related crashes on both crest and sag curves. Low speed limit on crest curves and high speed limit on sag curves increases truck-related crashes which may seem counter intuitive. The fifth objective is to provide suggestions on effective methods to reduce truck related crashes and improve safety. Some potential areas for design improvement may include flattening of steep vertical curves, advisory speed signs and increasing the roadway width on rural vertical curves in Ohio."--Abstract.
Author: John Naylor Ivan Publisher: ISBN: 9780309698580 Category : Roads Languages : en Pages : 0
Book Description
"This report presents guidelines on evaluating crash severity estimation models for use in different site conditions. The guidelines will be of interest to state departments of transportation (DOTs) seeking more informed model application, broader acceptance of model results, and, ultimately, improved safety decision making. The guidelines could also be applied to existing crash prediction models and serve to improve pertinent models and model elements in the Highway Safety Manual (HSM) and its associated tools." -- publisher's website
Author: Nancy Dutta
Author: Nancy Dutta
Author: 
Author: Mirza Ahammad Sharif
Author: 
Author: Gaurav Satish Mehta
Author: Abdulla Ali
Author: Yuanlin Huang
Author: Srutha Vavilikolanu
Author: Xiao Qin
Author: John Naylor Ivan