Author: Xiaoran YangPublisher:
ISBN:
Category :
Languages : en
Pages :
Book Description
Essays on Volatility Estimation and Forecasting of Crude Oil Futures
Author: Xiaoran YangEssays on Oil Price Volatility and Irreversible Investment
Author: Daniel Joseph PastorPublisher:
ISBN:
Category : Economics
Languages : en
Pages : 76
Book Description
In chapter 1, we provide an extensive and systematic evaluation of the relative forecasting performance of several models for the volatility of daily spot crude oil prices. Empirical research over the past decades has uncovered significant gains in forecasting performance of Markov Switching GARCH models over GARCH models for the volatility of financial assets and crude oil futures. We find that, for spot oil price returns, non-switching models perform better in the short run, whereas switching models tend to do better at longer horizons. In chapter 2, I investigate the impact of volatility on firms' irreversible investment decisions using real options theory. Cost incurred in oil drilling is considered sunk cost, thus irreversible. I collect detailed data on onshore, development oil well drilling on the North Slope of Alaska from 2003 to 2014. Volatility is modeled by constructing GARCH, EGARCH, and GJR-GARCH forecasts based on monthly real oil prices, and realized volatility from 5-minute intraday returns of oil futures prices. Using a duration model, I show that oil price volatility generally has a negative relationship with the hazard rate of drilling an oil well both when aggregating all the fields, and in individual fields.
Forecasting Accuracy of Crude Oil Futures Prices
Author: Mr.Manmohan S. KumarPublisher: International Monetary Fund
ISBN: 1451951116
Category : Business & Economics
Languages : en
Pages : 54
Book Description
This paper undertakes an investigation into the efficiency of the crude oil futures market and the forecasting accuracy of futures prices. Efficiency of the market is analysed in terms of the expected excess returns to speculation in the futures market. Accuracy of futures prices is compared with that of forecasts using alternative techniques, including time series and econometric models, as well as judgemental forecasts. The paper also explores the predictive power of futures prices by comparing the forecasting accuracy of end-of-month prices with weekly and monthly averages, using a variety of different weighting schemes. Finally, the paper investigates whether the forecasts from using futures prices can be improved by incorporating information from other forecasting techniques.
Volatility Forecasting for Crude Oil Futures
Author: Massimiliano MarzoTwo Essays on Crude Oil Futures and Options Markets
Author: Bingxin LiPublisher:
ISBN:
Category : Finance
Languages : en
Pages :
Book Description
This dissertation consists of two essays on crude oil futures and options markets. The first essay investigates whether aggregate risk aversion and risk premiums in the crude oil market co-vary with the level of speculation. Using crude oil futures and option data, I estimate aggregate risk aversion in the crude oil market and find that it is signi ficantly lower after 2002, when speculative activity started to increase. Using speculation index as a state variable, risk premiums implied by the state-dependent risk aversion estimates confi rm the negative correlation between speculative activity and risk premiums, and indicate that risk premiums in the crude oil market are on average lower and more volatile after 2002. These findings suggest that index-fund investors who demand commodity futures for the purpose of portfolio diversi fication are willing to accept lower compensation for their positions. Estimated state-dependent risk premiums have substantial predictive power for subsequent futures returns and outperform commonly used predictors. The second essay exams the economic importance of jumps, jump risk premiums, and dynamic jump intensities in crude oil futures and options markets. Existing pricing models for crude oil options are computationally intensive due to the presence of latent state variables. Using a panel data of crude oil futures and options, I implement a class of computationally e fficient discrete-time jump models. I find that jumps account for about half of the total variance in crude oil futures and options prices, and a substantial part of the risk premiums is due to jumps. Jumps are large and rare events in crude oil futures and options markets. The main role of jumps and jump risk premiums in crude oil futures and options markets is to capture excess kurtosis in the data. These findings suggest that it is critical to include jumps in pricing models for crude oil futures and options, and there is strong evidence in favor of time-varying jump intensities.
Essays on Volatility Forecasting and Density Estimation
Author: Shan LuEssays on Time-Varying Volatility and Structural Breaks in Macroeconomics and Econometrics
Author: Nyamekye AsarePublisher:
ISBN:
Category :
Languages : en
Pages :
Book Description
This thesis is comprised of three independent essays. One essay is in the field of macroeconomics and the other two are in time-series econometrics. The first essay, "Productivity and Business Investment over the Business Cycle", is co-authored with my co-supervisor Hashmat Khan. This essay documents a new stylized fact: the correlation between labour productivity and real business investment in the U.S. data switching from 0.54 to -0.1 in 1990. With the assistance of a bivariate VAR, we find that the response of investment to identified technology shocks has changed signs from positive to negative across two sub-periods: ranging from the time of the post-WWII era to the end of 1980s and from 1990 onwards, whereas the response to non-technology shocks has remained relatively unchanged. Also, the volatility of technology shocks declined less relative to the non-technology shocks. This raises the question of whether relatively more volatile technology shocks and the negative response of investment can together account for the decreased correlation. To answer this question, we consider a canonical DSGE model and simulate data under a variety of assumptions about the parameters representing structural features and volatility of shocks. The second and third essays are in time series econometrics and solely authored by myself. The second essay, however, focuses on the impact of ignoring structural breaks in the conditional volatility parameters on time-varying volatility parameters. The focal point of the third essay is on empirical relevance of structural breaks in time-varying volatility models and the forecasting gains of accommodating structural breaks in the unconditional variance. There are several ways in modeling time-varying volatility. One way is to use the autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity (ARCH)/generalized ARCH (GARCH) class first introduced by Engle (1982) and Bollerslev (1986). One prominent model is Bollerslev (1986) GARCH model in which the conditional volatility is updated by its own residuals and its lags. This class of models is popular amongst practitioners in finance because they are able to capture stylized facts about asset returns such as fat tails and volatility clustering (Engle and Patton, 2001; Zivot, 2009) and require maximum likelihood methods for estimation. They also perform well in forecasting volatility. For example, Hansen and Lunde (2005) find that it is difficult to beat a simple GARCH(1,1) model in forecasting exchange rate volatility. Another way of modeling time-varying volatility is to use the class of stochastic volatility (SV) models including Taylor's (1986) autoregressive stochastic volatility (ARSV) model. With SV models, the conditional volatility is updated only by its own lags and increasingly used in macroeconomic modeling (i.e.Justiniano and Primiceri (2010)). Fernandez-Villaverde and Rubio-Ramirez (2010) claim that the stochastic volatility model fits better than the GARCH model and is easier to incorporate into DSGE models. However, Creal et al. (2013) recently introduced a new class of models called the generalized autoregressive score (GAS) models. With the GAS volatility framework, the conditional variance is updated by the scaled score of the model's density function instead of the squared residuals. According to Creal et al. (2013), GAS models are advantageous to use because updating the conditional variance using the score of the log-density instead of the second moments can improve a model's fit to data. They are also found to be less sensitive to other forms of misspecification such as outliers. As mentioned by Maddala and Kim (1998), structural breaks are considered to be one form of outliers. This raises the question about whether GAS volatility models are less sensitive to parameter non-constancy. This issue of ignoring structural breaks in the volatility parameters is important because neglecting breaks can cause the conditional variance to exhibit unit root behaviour in which the unconditional variance is undefined, implying that any shock to the variance will not gradually decline (Lamoureux and Lastrapes, 1990). The impact of ignoring parameter non-constancy is found in GARCH literature (see Lamoureux and Lastrapes, 1990; Hillebrand, 2005) and in SV literature (Psaradakis and Tzavalis, 1999; Kramer and Messow, 2012) in which the estimated persistence parameter overestimates its true value and approaches one. However, it has never been addressed in GAS literature until now. The second essay uses a simple Monte-Carlo simulation study to examine the impact of neglecting parameter non-constancy on the estimated persistence parameter of several GAS and non-GAS models of volatility. Five different volatility models are examined. Of these models, three --the GARCH(1,1), t-GAS(1,1), and Beta-t-EGARCH(1,1) models -- are GAS models, while the other two -- the t-GARCH(1,1) and EGARCH(1,1) models -- are not. Following Hillebrand (2005) who studied only the GARCH model, this essay examines the extent of how biased the estimated persistence parameter are by assessing impact of ignoring breaks on the mean value of the estimated persistence parameter. The impact of neglecting parameter non-constancy on the empirical sampling distributions and coverage probabilities for the estimated persistence parameters are also studied in this essay. For the latter, studying the effect on the coverage probabilities is important because a decrease in coverage probabilities is associated with an increase in Type I error. This study has implications for forecasting. If the size of an ignored break in parameters is small, then there may not be any gains in using forecast methods that accommodate breaks. Empirical evidence suggests that structural breaks are present in data on macro-financial variables such as oil prices and exchange rates. The potentially serious consequences of ignoring a break in GARCH parameters motivated Rapach and Strauss (2008) and Arouri et al. (2012) to study the empirical relevance of structural breaks in the context of GARCH models. However, the literature does not address the empirical relevance of structural breaks in the context of GAS models. The third and final essay contributes to this literature by extending Rapach and Strauss (2008) to include the t-GAS model and by comparing its performance to that of two non-GAS models, the t-GARCH and SV models. The empirical relevance of structural breaks in the models of volatility is assessed using a formal test by Dufour and Torres (1998) to determine how much the estimated parameters change over sub-periods. The in-sample performance of all the models is analyzed using both the weekly USD trade-weighted index between January 1973 and October 2016 and spot oil prices based on West Texas Intermediate between January 1986 and October 2016. The full sample is split into smaller subsamples by break dates chosen based on historical events and policy changes rather than formal tests. This is because commonly-used tests such as CUSUM suffer from low power (Smith, 2008; Xu, 2013). For each sub-period, all models are estimated using either oil or USD returns. The confidence intervals are constructed for the constant of the conditional parameter and the score parameter (or ARCH parameter in GARCH and t-GARCH models). Then Dufour and Torres's union-intersection test is applied to these confidence intervals to determine how much the estimated parameter change over sub-periods. If there is a set of values that intersects the confidence intervals of all sub-periods, then one can conclude that the parameters do not change that much. The out-of-sample performance of all time-varying volatility models are also assessed in the ability to forecast the mean and variance of oil and USD returns. Through this analysis, this essay also addresses whether using models that accommodate structural breaks in the unconditional variance of both GAS and non-GAS models will improve forecasts.
Essays in Applied Econometrics of High Frequency Financial Data
Author: Ilya ArchakovPublisher:
ISBN:
Category :
Languages : en
Pages : 173
Book Description
In the first chapter, co-authored with Peter Hansen and Asger Lunde, we suggest a novel approach to modeling and measuring systematic risk in equity markets. We develop a new modeling framework that treats an asset return as a dependent variable in a multiple regression model. The GARCH-type dynamics of conditional variances and correlations between the regression variables naturally imply a temporal variation of regression coefficients (betas). The model incorporates extra information from the realized (co-)variance measures extracted from high frequency data, which helps to better identify the latent covariance process and capture its changes more promptly. The suggested structure is consistent with the broad class of linear factor models in the asset pricing literature. We apply our framework to the famous three-factor Fama-French model at the daily frequency. Throughout the empirical analysis, we consider more than 800 individual stocks as well as style and sectoral exchange traded funds from the U.S. equity market. We document an appreciable cross-sectional and temporal variation of the model-implied risk loadings with the especially strong (though short-lived) distortion around the Financial Crisis episode. In addition, we find a significant heterogeneity in a relative explanatory power of the Fama-French factors across the different sectors of economy and detect a fluctuation of the risk premia estimates over time. The empirical evidence emphasizes the importance of taking into account dynamic aspects of the underlying covariance structure in asset pricing models. In the second chapter, written with Bo Laursen, we extend the popular dynamic Nelson-Siegel framework by introducing time-varying volatilities in the factor dynamics and incorporating the realized measures to improve the identification of the latent volatility state. The new model is able to effectively describe the conditional distribution dynamics of a term structure variable and can still be readily estimated with the Kalman filter. We apply our framework to model the crude oil futures prices. Using more than 150,000,000 transactions for the large panel of contracts we carefully construct the realized volatility measures corresponding to the latent Nelson-Siegel factors, estimate the model at daily frequency and evaluate it by forecasting the conditional density of futures prices. We document that the time-varying volatility specification suggested in our model strongly outperforms the constant volatility benchmark. In addition, the use of realized measures provides moderate, but systematic gains in density forecasting. In the third chapter, I investigate the rate at which information about the daily asset volatility level arrives with the transaction data in the course of the trading day. The contribution of this analysis is three-fold. First, I gauge how fast (after the market opening) the reasonable projection of the new daily volatility level can be constructed. Second, the framework provides a natural experimental field for the comparison of the small sample properties of different types of estimators as well as their (very) short-run forecasting capability. Finally, I outline an adaptive modeling framework for volatility dynamics that attaches time-varying weights to the different predictive signals in response to the changing stochastic environment. In the empirical analysis, I consider a sample of assets from the Dow Jones index. I find that the average precision of the ex-post daily volatility projections made after only 15 minutes of trading (at 9:45a.m. EST) amounts to 65% (in terms of predictive R2) and reaches up to 90% before noon. Moreover, in conjunction with the prior forecast, the first 15 minutes of trading are able to predict about 80% of the ex-post daily volatility. I document that the predictive content of the realized measures that use data at the transaction frequency is strongly superior as compared to the estimators that use sparsely sampled data, but the difference is getting negligible closer to the end of the trading day, as more observations are used to construct a projection. In the final chapter, joint with Peter Hansen, Guillaume Horel and Asger Lunde, we introduce a multivariate estimator of financial volatility that is based on the theory of Markov chains. The Markov chain framework takes advantage of the discreteness of high-frequency returns and suggests a natural decomposition of the observed price process into a martingale and a stationary components. The new estimator is robust to microstructural noise effects and is positive semidefinite by construction. We outline an approach to the estimation of high dimensional covariance matrices. This approach overcomes the curse of dimensionality caused by the tremendous number of observed price transitions (normally, exceeding 10,000 per trading day) that complicates a reliable estimation of the transition probability matrix for the multivariate Markov chain process. We study the finite sample properties of the estimator in a simulation study and apply it to high-frequency commodity prices. We find that the new estimator demonstrates a decent finite sample precision. The empirical estimates are largely in agreement with the benchmarks, but the Markov chain estimator is found to be particularly well with regards to estimating correlations.
Essays on Volatility Forecasting
Author: Dimos S. KambouroudisPublisher:
ISBN:
Category : Accounting and price fluctuations
Languages : en
Pages : 522
Book Description
Stock market volatility has been an important subject in the finance literature for which now an enormous body of research exists. Volatility modelling and forecasting have been in the epicentre of this line of research and although more than a few models have been proposed and key parameters on improving volatility forecasts have been considered, finance research has still to reach a consensus on this topic. This thesis enters the ongoing debate by carrying out empirical investigations by comparing models from the current pool of models as well as exploring and proposing the use of further key parameters in improving the accuracy of volatility modelling and forecasting. The importance of accurately forecasting volatility is paramount for the functioning of the economy and everyone involved in finance activities. For governments, the banking system, institutional and individual investors, researchers and academics, knowledge, understanding and the ability to forecast and proxy volatility accurately is a determining factor for making sound economic decisions. Four are the main contributions of this thesis. First, the findings of a volatility forecasting model comparison reveal that the GARCH genre of models are superior compared to the more 'simple' models and models preferred by practitioners. Second, with the use of backward recursion forecasts we identify the appropriate in-sample length for producing accurate volatility forecasts, a parameter considered for the first time in the finance literature. Third, further model comparisons are conducted within a Value-at-Risk setting between the RiskMetrics model preferred by practitioners, and the more complex GARCH type models, arriving to the conclusion that GARCH type models are dominant. Finally, two further parameters, the Volatility Index (VIX) and Trading Volume, are considered and their contribution is assessed in the modelling and forecasting process of a selection of GARCH type models. We discover that although accuracy is improved upon, GARCH type forecasts are still superior.
Essays in Risk Management for Crude Oil Markets
Author: Abdullah Al MansourPublisher:
ISBN:
Category :
Languages : en
Pages : 140
Book Description
This thesis consists of three essays on risk management in crude oil markets. In the first essay, the valuation of an oil sands project is studied using real options approach. Oil sands production consumes substantial amount of natural gas during extracting and upgrading. Natural gas prices are known to be stochastic and highly volatile which introduces a risk factor that needs to be taken into account. The essay studies the impact of this risk factor on the value of an oil sands project and its optimal operation. The essay takes into account the co-movement between crude oil and natural gas markets and, accordingly, proposes two models: one incorporates a long-run link between the two markets while the other has no such link. The valuation problem is solved using the Least Square Monte Carlo (LSMC) method proposed by Longstaff and Schwartz (2001) for valuing American options. The valuation results show that incorporating a long-run relationship between the two markets is a very crucial decision in the value of the project and in its optimal operation. The essay shows that ignoring this long-run relationship makes the optimal policy sensitive to the dynamics of natural gas prices. On the other hand, incorporating this long-run relationship makes the dynamics of natural gas price process have a very low impact on valuation and the optimal operating policy. In the second essay, the relationship between the slope of the futures term structure, or the forward curve, and volatility in the crude oil market is investigated using a measure of the slope based on principal component analysis (PCA). The essay begins by reviewing the main theories of the relation between spot and futures prices and considering the implication of each theory on the relation between the slope of the forward curve and volatility. The diagonal VECH model of Bollerslev et al. (1988) was used to analyse the relationship between of the forward curve slope and the variances of the spot and futures prices and the covariance between them. The results show that there is a significant quadratic relationship and that exploiting this relation improves the hedging performance using futures contracts. The third essay attempts to model the spot price process of crude oil using the notion of convenience yield in a regime switching framework. Unlike the existing studies, which assume the convenience yield to have either a constant value or to have a stochastic behaviour with mean reversion to one equilibrium level, the model of this essay extends the Brennan and Schwartz (1985) model to allows for regime switching in the convenience yield along with the other parameters. In the essay, a closed form solution for the futures price is derived. The parameters are estimated using an extension to the Kalman filter proposed by Kim (1994). The regime switching one-factor model of this study does a reasonable job and the transitional probabilities play an important role in shaping the futures term structure implied by the model.