Author: Miguel Minutti-Meza Publisher: ISBN: Category : Languages : en Pages :
Book Description
This study examines whether auditor industry specialization, measured using the auditor's within-industry market share, improves audit quality and results in a fee premium. After matching clients of specialist and non-specialist auditors on a number of dimensions, as well as only on industry and size, there is no evidence of differences in commonly used audit-quality proxies between these two groups of auditors. Moreover, there is no consistent evidence of a specialist fee premium. The matched-sample results are confirmed by including client fixed effects in the main models, examining a sample of clients that switched auditors, and using an alternative proxy that aims to capture the auditor's industry knowledge. The combined evidence in this study suggests that the auditor's within-industry market share is not a reliable indicator of audit quality. Nevertheless, these findings do not imply that industry knowledge is not important for auditors, but that the methodology used in extant archival studies to examine this issue does not fully parse out the effects of auditor industry specialization from client characteristics.
Author: Chee Yeow Lim Publisher: ISBN: Category : Languages : en Pages : 42
Book Description
We investigate whether the relation between auditor tenure and audit quality is conditional on auditor specialization and fee dependence. Although prior studies have investigated the relation between extended auditor-client tenure and audit quality, none has examined how this relation is jointly influenced by both auditor specialization and fee dependence. Our main analyses, using accrual quality as a measure of audit quality, show that firms audited by specialists (vs. non-specialists) have relatively higher audit quality with extended auditor tenure, and that this relation is negatively moderated by auditors' fee dependence on clients. These results are robust to sensitivity tests, and alternative proxies for audit quality such as the issuance of going concern opinions and the market's response to quarterly earnings surprises.
Author: Jagan Krishnan Publisher: ISBN: Category : Languages : en Pages :
Book Description
This study compares the earnings response coefficients of clients of industry specialist and non-specialist auditors. Prior work (e.g., DeAngelo 1981) has suggested that auditors offer different levels of audit quality, in response to client variations in the demand for different levels of audit quality (Watts and Zimmerman 1986). One component of the quality difference across auditors is industry specialization (Craswell et al. 1995). Empirical evidence on the effect of industry specialization on audit quality proxies such as audit fees, auditor litigation and compliance with accounting standards is mixed. This study examines the hypothesis that industry specialization leads to a better quality of audit by comparing the earnings response coefficients of clients audited by industry specialists with those of clients not audited by industry specialists. Teoh and Wong (1993) argue that audit quality is positively associated with the client's quality of earnings and therefore the earnings response coefficient (ERC), which is the responsiveness of the stock market to information about unexpected earnings. They present evidence that one measure of audit quality, auditors' brand-name (Big 6 or not), is positively associated with the ERC. This paper extends this argument by examining the effect of another facet of audit quality, auditor industry specialization, on the ERC. The results suggest that, after controlling for previously established correlates of the ERC, as well as industry affiliation, clients of industry specialist auditors have higher ERCs than clients of non-specialist auditors.
Author: Debra C. Jeter Publisher: ISBN: Category : Languages : en Pages :
Book Description
As audit quality is paramount in returning the profession to the “priesthood” in the wake of accounting scandals such as Enron and bank failures, perhaps the most important question with respect to industry specialization is whether or not industry specialists provide truly superior quality audits. Research in industry specialization by auditors has focused to date primarily on addressing this question; the pricing of audits by specialists is a related issue also examined in a number of studies. Research suggests that specialists are associated with higher earnings quality for their auditees, whether due to intervention in the reporting process, or because management anticipates such intervention and constrains opportunistic earnings management. The role of industry specialization in audit pricing has been frequently addressed in the literature, and yet remains largely unresolved. Some studies present evidence of specialist premiums, while others find no premiums or premiums only for certain subsets of clients. In its 2003 report, the GAO expressed some concern that auditor choice was limited for large national and multinational companies requiring industry-specific expertise, noting that an auditor who audits a number of smaller companies within an industry may not have the necessary expertise to handle the larger clients in that industry. Most researchers, however, find little evidence of adverse impacts such as oligopolistic pricing as a result of the increased audit market concentration resulting from the audit firm mergers and demise of Arthur Andersen. Industry specialization, if pursued as a means of enhancing the knowledge and understanding necessary to conduct superior audits, should result in benefits to both client and auditor. Industry specialists may be able to provide higher levels of assurance because they are more likely to assess risks, and to detect financial reporting errors and irregularities, and are thus equipped to deliver better planned and more effective audits.
Author: Vani K. Borooah Publisher: SAGE ISBN: 9780761922421 Category : Mathematics Languages : en Pages : 108
Book Description
Many problems in the social sciences are amenable to analysis using the analytical tools of logit and probit models. This book explains what ordered and multinomial models are and also shows how to apply them to analysing issues in the social sciences.
Author: Mohamed A. Hegazy Publisher: ISBN: Category : Languages : en Pages : 23
Book Description
This paper aims at investigating the effect of industry specialization on the audit quality and earnings quality. It examines the relation between industry specialization and earnings quality, financial reporting quality, and audit quality. The research posits that industry specialization constrains earnings management. In addition, it hypothesized a positive relationship between industry specialization and financial reporting quality. An experiment was conducted in an audit firm with international affiliation in Egypt to test the research hypotheses. The results indicate that there is no significant difference between industry specialist auditors and non-specialists in constraining earnings management. In addition, findings support that financial reporting quality was significantly higher when specialists conducted the audit. The results provide empirical evidence consistent with the hypothesis that auditor with industry specialization improves audit quality. Finally, industry specialization enables auditors to realize the amendments in auditing standards better than non-specialists.
Author: Cory A. Cassell Publisher: ISBN: Category : Languages : en Pages : 47
Book Description
Using a measure of office-level industry concentration/specialization (as opposed to a market-based measure), we identify situations in which auditor industry specialization could be detrimental for audit outcomes. In stable environments, industry specialist auditors should be able to apply their unique experience and knowledge in ways that yield better audit outcomes. However, during periods of heightened industry-specific risk, specialist auditors from the affected industry could struggle to secure and allocate sufficient resources to mitigate the heightened risk in the affected industry because, by construction, specialists in the affected industry have a client portfolio that is concentrated in the affected industry (i.e., there is insufficient resource slack). We test our predictions by investigating the effects of the recent financial crisis on audits of clients from the banking industry. We find that, during the period before the financial crisis, banking auditor industry specialization is associated with higher audit quality and more timely audits. However, during the financial crisis, the results indicate that banking auditor industry specialization is associated with lower audit quality and less timely audits. Collectively, our results suggest that auditor office-level industry specialization can be detrimental in certain circumstances and that audit firms and audit regulators should consider whether the audit market, audit firms, or audit offices have become too specialized to handle the resource allocation problems that crisis situations present.
Author: Kimberly Dunn Publisher: ISBN: Category : Languages : en Pages : 29
Book Description
We examine the relation between audit firm industry specialization and client disclosure quality. Our motivation for conducting this research arises from the claims made by each of the Big5 public accounting firms that industry specialization enables each to provide superior service and quality to clients in its target industries.We document a positive association between industry-specialized audit firms and analysts' rankings of disclosure quality in unregulated industries, but no relation in regulated industries. Alternative measures of auditor industry specialization support our conclusions. Our results suggest industry-specialized audit firms add value to clients in unregulated industries in the form of improved disclosure quality.
Author: Miguel Minutti-Meza
Author: Chee Yeow Lim
Author: Miguel Minutti Meza
Author: Jagan Krishnan
Author: Miguel Angel Minutti Meza
Author: Debra C. Jeter
Author: Vani K. Borooah
Author: Mohamed A. Hegazy
Author: Cory A. Cassell
Author: Kimberly Dunn